Citing Ezekiel 37:19 is ineffectual to serve the purposes of the Mormons. The passage itself is simply too vague. For example, Jehovah's Witnesses could appeal to this text to make the same argument in favor of the Watchtower Society and its magazine publications. Any group of people could appeal to this passage in the way that Mormons have done to support their claims.
The only thing that Ezekiel recorded on to the stick was the phrase, "For Joseph, the stick of Ephraim and all the house of Israel, his companions." (Ezekiel 37:16) That was all that God had told Ezekiel to write on the stick. Therefore, Mormons are wrong when they assert that the Book of Mormon was what was written on the stick by the prophet.
In context, the Jewish people asked Ezekiel, ‘Wilt thou not show us what thou meanest by these?’ (Ezekiel 37:18). The joining of the two sticks represents the divided state of Israel. The northern kingdoms and the southern kingdoms constitute the nation of Judah. It is about them being reunited again (Ezekiel 37:21-22). The two sticks represent the union of two kingdoms, not two different religious books.
Mormons impose 19th-century religious ideas onto an ancient Hebrew prophecy without historical or linguistic evidence. Further, the passage's original context pertains to the reunification of Israel's divided tribes, with no reference to religious texts or future scripture. This interpretive leap, therefore, undermines the legitimacy and historical accuracy of using Ezekiel's prophecy to validate the Book of Mormon.
