Tuesday, June 11, 2019

How Christ’s Incarnation Differs From The Hindu Idea Of Avatar

Jesus Christ’s life, death, and miraculous resurrection are events rooted in history. Whereas the lives of the Hindu holy men are enveloped in mythology.

As an Eastern mystical religion, Hinduism does not emphasize chronology. And modern-day Hindus show little interest in the “historical” Krishna the way contemporary Christians inquire about the historicity of Jesus.

Scholar and Krishna devotee Mataji Devi Vanamali explains:

“Hinduism is not a historical religion. If somebody were to prove conclusively that Krishna, Rama, and the various gods of the Hindu pantheon never existed, most Hindus would not mind in the least, and the religion would continue to flourish as it has done for so many centuries. However, to the devotees of Krishna, he is as real as any of their friends or relatives or children, depending on how they regard him—as friend, relation, child, or lover. This being so, most Indians have not bothered to verify his existence.”1

Thus a major difference between Jesus Christ and the Hindu holy men (including Krishna) relates to history and the question of historical verification.

1. Vanamali, The Complete Life of Krishna: Based on the Earliest Oral Traditions and Sacred Scriptures (Rochester, VT: Inner Traditions, 2012), xiii-xiv.

Kenneth Samples, cited by Ken Temple

2 comments:

  1. It turns out that my next article will be an expose on Hinduism. it will be out sometime friday, Lord willing. You have a good point. One of the greatest differences imo between hinduism and christianity is that we have overwhelming evidence that the events that happened in scripture are true whereas even though I haven't read them I dare venture to say that the stories of the vedas/hindu holy books have little to no historical backing. Have you read them Jesse? Would you agree?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Justin,

    I will read your material whenever you choose to publish it on your blog.

    And no, I have not read the sacred texts of Hinduism on my own at this point in time. Nonetheless, you might find this article of interest:

    https://rationalchristiandiscernment.blogspot.com/2017/02/circular-reasoning-used-in-survival-of.html

    ReplyDelete